Small Business Employee Benefits: What to Offer and How to Afford It
Small businesses can offer real employee benefits without a big-company budget. The key is choosing the right structure for your size, focusing on the benefits employees value most, and adding options that cost your business little or nothing.
This guide covers whether small businesses have to offer benefits, the best employee benefits for a small business, what they cost, and how to build a small business employee benefits package step by step.
Do small businesses have to provide benefits?
Every small business with W-2 employees must provide a few benefits required by law: Social Security and Medicare contributions, unemployment insurance, and workers' compensation in most states. Texas is the one state where workers' comp is optional for most private employers.
Health insurance is different. Employers with fewer than 50 employees (measured as full-time employees plus full-time equivalents) aren't required to provide health insurance under the Affordable Care Act. Small employers can also compare plans through the Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP). But in a tight hiring market, small business benefits are often what separates you from the employer down the street. Many small businesses start offering employee benefits simply to hire and keep good people.
See our employer's guide to statutory employee benefits for the full list of required benefits.
The importance of employee benefits for small businesses
Every employee benefit you offer sends a message about how much you value your team. Competitive employee benefits help a small business:
- Compete for talent against larger employers that offer full benefit packages
- Improve retention, since replacing an employee costs far more than keeping one
- Help employees stay healthy, productive and financially secure
- Lower taxes, because employer-paid health insurance and retirement contributions are generally tax-deductible
The best employee benefits for a small business
The best employee benefits for a small business are the ones your team values most and you can sustain year after year. For most small businesses, that means:
Health insurance
Health insurance is the most requested benefit. Your main options for small business health coverage:
| Option | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Small group health plan | A traditional health insurance plan from a carrier; you pay part of the premium | Teams that want a familiar, full plan |
| Level-funded plan | A fixed monthly cost, with a possible refund if claims are low | Healthier groups looking to control costs |
| QSEHRA | You reimburse employees tax-free for individual health coverage, up to an annual IRS limit | Employers under 50 that want a set budget |
| ICHRA | Like a QSEHRA but more flexible, for any size of employer | Teams spread across locations or roles |
Read more in our beginner's guide to level-funded health insurance.
Retirement savings plans
A retirement plan helps employees save and helps you retain them:
- 401(k): Works for a small business of any size. A safe harbor design simplifies compliance testing, and federal tax credits can offset startup costs for small employers.
- SIMPLE IRA: Low cost and easy to run, for employers with 100 or fewer employees.
- 403(b): For nonprofits and churches.
Life and disability insurance
Group life insurance and disability insurance are inexpensive for a small business and protect employees' families and income. Many small businesses pay for a basic life insurance benefit and let employees buy additional coverage through payroll deduction. Disability insurance replaces part of an employee's paycheck if illness or injury keeps them from working, which is a benefit employees value more than most employers expect.
Dental and vision
Dental and vision plans are low-cost additions that employees use often.
Voluntary benefits
Voluntary benefits, like accident, critical illness and hospital insurance, are paid by employees through payroll deduction. They expand your benefit package at little or no cost to the business.
Flexible work and paid time off
Flexible schedules, remote work and paid time off cost little and rank high with employees. Policies that allow employees to work from home or adjust their hours support employee well-being and employee loyalty.
Wellness programs and employee assistance programs
A wellness program and employee assistance programs (EAPs) give employees confidential counseling, mental health support and resources for employees and their families. Many EAPs are included at no extra cost with group life or disability coverage.
Health savings accounts
Pairing a high-deductible health plan with a health savings account (HSA) lets employees set aside pre-tax money for health care costs, and lowers premiums for the business.
Examples of unique benefits for a small business
Beyond the core benefits, small businesses may stand out with low-cost extras that employees remember:
- Tuition or certification reimbursement
- Paid volunteer days
- Commuter or cell phone stipends
- Paid parental or caregiver leave
- Birthday or work-anniversary days off
These additional benefits help build a competitive small business employee benefits program without the cost of traditional benefits alone.
Managing benefits administration
Benefits administration, meaning enrollment, payroll deductions, new-hire paperwork and annual renewals, can feel overwhelming for small business owners. A good benefits provider or broker handles most of it for you, so offering benefits to employees doesn't become a second job.
How much do employee benefits cost a small business?
Costs depend on your location, industry, the ages of your employees, the plans you choose and how much you contribute. Health insurance is usually the largest cost. Many small businesses control it by:
- Paying a fixed share of employee-only premiums and letting employees pay to add dependents
- Choosing a level-funded plan or an HRA instead of a traditional plan
- Adding voluntary benefits instead of employer-paid extras
- Re-shopping coverage with several carriers every year
The fastest way to know your real cost is a side-by-side quote based on your team.
How to build a small business employee benefits package
- Set your budget. Decide what your business can spend per employee per month.
- Ask employees what they value. A short survey helps you avoid paying for benefits nobody uses.
- Pick your health insurance structure. Group plan, level-funded plan or HRA.
- Add a retirement plan. Even a simple plan without a match helps employees save.
- Round it out with low-cost benefits. Life, disability, dental, vision and voluntary benefits.
- Compare carriers side by side. Prices and networks vary widely for the same coverage.
- Explain the package clearly. Benefits only help retention if employees understand them.
- Review it every year as your business needs and team change.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best employee benefits for a small business?
Health insurance, a retirement plan, paid time off and flexible work are the benefits employees value most. Life, disability and voluntary benefits round out a strong package at low cost.
Can a small business offer benefits on a tight budget?
Yes. HRAs let you set a fixed monthly amount, level-funded plans can lower health costs, and voluntary benefits cost the employer little or nothing.
What benefits are required by law for small businesses?
Social Security and Medicare contributions, unemployment insurance, and workers' compensation in most states. Health insurance is required only for employers with 50 or more full-time equivalents.
What are the benefits of working at a small company?
Employees at a small company often get more flexibility, closer relationships with leadership, and a bigger say in their work. When a small business pairs that with solid employee benefits, like health insurance and a retirement plan, it can compete with much larger employers for talent.
What are the downsides of working for a small company?
The most common concern is fewer or weaker employee benefits than large employers offer. That's why a well-designed small business employee benefits package matters: it removes the biggest reason a good candidate might choose a larger company instead.
How do I choose a health insurance plan for my small business?
Compare deductibles, provider networks and monthly premiums across several carriers, then match the health insurance plan to your employees' needs and your budget. An independent broker can quote multiple carriers at once.
Should a small business offer a retirement plan?
Yes, if you can. A retirement plan is one of the most valued employee benefits, helps employees build retirement savings, and federal tax credits can offset much of the startup cost for a small business.
Let's find the right fit
Benefits On Us works with small businesses nationwide, from 2-person shops to growing teams. Book a free 15-minute Discovery Call and we'll show you small business employee benefits options that fit your budget.
Download Our Free Benefits Guide
Get practical steps and benchmark data to help build a cost-effective benefits package.
Group Benefits for Small Business
Build a benefits package that fits your small business budget.
Ready to review your employee benefits?
Schedule a complimentary 15-minute consultation or request a custom quote from A-rated carriers.
- No obligation or pressure
- Plain language guidance
- Multiple carrier options